The Fancy Nancy Grilled Cheese

“Fresh mozzarella and rich gorgonzola go perfectly with the flavors of pesto and bacon. Enjoy the grilled cheese as they are, or dip them into your favorite tomato soup.” – Andrea Chetakian

Wisconsin Cheese The Fancy Nancy Grilled Cheese Recipe
Active Time
35 Minutes


Parmesan Pesto:

Balsamic Reduction:

Grilled Cheese Sandwiches:


Look for the Proudly Wisconsin Badge when shopping for cheese. Any brand of Wisconsin Fresh Mozzarella, Gorgonzola or Parmesan can be used in this recipe.


Parmesan Pesto:

  1. Place basil, pine nuts, garlic and salt into food processor; cover and pulse until finely chopped. While processing, slowly drizzle in olive oil until smooth. Add parmesan; cover and pulse until blended.

Balsamic Reduction:

  1. Bring balsamic vinegar to a boil in a small skillet over medium-high heat. Reduce heat to medium. Stir in honey; simmer, uncovered, stirring until balsamic-honey mixture is reduced by half and slightly thickened. Remove from the heat. Cool slightly.

Grilled Cheese Sandwiches:

  1. Spread 1 tablespoon pesto on each bread slice. Layer four bread slices with mozzarella, bacon and gorgonzola. Drizzle each with balsamic reduction. Top with remaining bread slices pesto side down. Spread mayonnaise on the outside of sandwiches, lightly pressing together. Cover and refrigerate any remaining pesto; save for a different recipe.
  2. Toast one sandwich, covered, in a large nonstick skillet over medium-low heat for 2-3 minutes or until side is golden brown. Flip sandwich; cook, uncovered, 2-4 minutes longer or until bread is golden brown and cheeses are melted. Repeat step with remaining sandwiches.

Cheesemonger Tip

Select for cheesemonger info

Do you have questions when shopping for cheese? Ask the cheesemonger! A cheesemonger specializes in the buying and selling of high-quality cheese, usually available in the specialty section of a grocery store or cheese shop. Knowledgeable and passionate, a cheesemonger is a go-to resource for cheese varieties and pairings, proper cheese storage and handling, its cooking applications and cheese brand information.

Salemville® Amish Gorgonzola cheese is a small-batch, artisanal blue-veined cheese that’s creamy and crumbly.

write a review